All Good Diapers Review

All Good Diapers Review, 2022: All Good, Or No Good?

Just as parents are becoming more aware of the hidden nasties in disposable diapers, diaper brands are improving their marketing tactics. There seems to be a new diaper variety popping up on the market every day right now, with companies using all kinds of buzzwords that turn our heads, from ‘natural’ to ‘eco-friendly’ to ‘non-toxic’. But what’s the truth?

All Good diapers were launched in 2020, exclusive to Walmart. Owned by P&G, they’re the diaper ‘for millennials’. Millennial parents, unsurprisingly, are harder to please when it comes to baby products. We want the best, the healthiest, and the most eco-conscious products only. 

So how do All Good diapers really stack up? Do they steer clear of nasty chemicals, and do their bit to minimize their impact on the planet’s resources? Or is it just clever branding?

Here’s everything you need to know about All Good diapers!

Disclaimer: Pampers Diapers has not sponsored or endorsed this article in any way. As a mom who’s passionate about buying the best for babies, I try really hard to include accurate information in all of my posts. If there are any inaccuracies present, please let me know; I’m more than happy to amend any errors. For more information about Pampers Diapers, head over to their main site: pampers.com This review has affiliate links. I may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you if you make a purchase through my affiliate link. Please read my disclosure for more info.

What are All Good Diapers made of?

I’d expect All Good diapers to be made from… well, all good ingredients. 

The best diapers for the environment are those which make a conscious effort to use as many plant-based materials as possible. These might be bamboo, wood, or cane. Unfortunately, although a part of the diaper is made from wood pulp, it doesn’t look like All Good diapers contain all good materials.

In fact, their diapers are made predominantly with petroleum-based plastics. Here’s a full list of the materials used:

Part of the diaperMaterials
TopsheetPolypropylene Nonwoven
Super Absorbent Polymer (SAP)Polyacrylate Polymer
Absorbent Wood PulpFluff pulp
Acquisition LayerPolyester
Backsheet filmPolyethylene
Backsheet CoveringPolypropylene

Most of these difficult-to-pronounce ingredients – the ones beginning with ‘poly’ – are various types of plastics. Apart from the wood pulp, the vast majority of the diaper is made with these petroleum-based plastics.

Compared to brands like Andy Pandy, which produces diapers made of 87% biodegradable materials – this isn’t great!

Related Post: What Are The Best Organic Diapers On The Market, And Why You Should Look For The Most Natural Ingredients

Are all good diapers clean?

You might be surprised to learn that many disposable diapers contain chemicals and toxins that should be nowhere near your baby’s sensitive skin. The use of many of these chemicals isn’t regulated by the FDA, which goes some way to explaining how brands manage to use them, despite health concerns. 

Phthalates, fragrances, and lotions, in particular, should be avoided where possible.

Phthalates are used in vinyl flooring, children’s toys, and disposable baby diapers. Shockingly, they’ve been linked to the increased risk of asthma and eczema in young children, as well as abnormal genital development in little boys. Why brands are still able to use them is anyone’s guess…

Fragrances and lotions are terms that can be used to cover a multitude of toxins and nasties present in a diaper. So it’s no wonder that diapers with these unnecessary additions can irritate your baby’s sensitive skin.

But what about All Good diapers?

All Good diapers are free of:

  • lotions
  • fragrances
  • latex

I couldn’t find any information on phthalates, though. If a brand doesn’t tell you that it avoids a certain chemical, it’s best to assume it is used! 

All Good diapers are also elemental chlorine-free, but not completely chlorine-free. Chlorine isn’t necessarily harmful to the skin, but it’s terrible for the environment and should be avoided if it’s possible. 

Read more about what’s in disposable baby diapers here!

What company owns All Good Diapers? 

All Good Diapers is owned by Procter & Gamble, or P&G as they’re otherwise known. P&G is a conglomerate that also owns the likes of Charlie Banana (cloth diapers), Luvs, and that little old brand, Pampers. 

The All Good diaper brand might be socially responsible, but we can’t forget how big corporations like P&G treat animals. It might not come as a shock that many of the brands owned by P&G carry out animal testing ‘when required to by law’, including various beauty and household cleaning brands. Some of the ingredients in diaper brands owned by P&G may even be tested directly on animals, although it’s hard to find any concrete information on this. 

For more about animal testing and animal ingredients in diapers, check out my complete guide to the best cruelty-free diapers!

Where are All Good diapers made?

All Good Diapers diapers price

*Prices were accurate at the time this article was published but may change over time.

Price is a big factor for most of us when it comes to baby diapers. While some diapers can set you back as little as 10 cents per diaper, others can cost you anything up to 70 or 80 cents! 

All Good diapers seem to be somewhere in the middle…

A 104 pack of size 1 diapers will cost you just under 20 bucks, or 19 cents per diaper. Size 3 diapers will cost you about 22 cents per diaper (for a 168 pack) and a 108 pack of size 6 diapers costs about 35 cents per diaper.

Considering that All Good diapers might contain phthalates, aren’t completely free of chlorine, and don’t boast any eco-credentials, these prices are certainly on the higher side. In fact, they’re comparable to brands like Abby & Finn and Hello Bello, which are free of harsh toxins, and use at least some plant-based materials. 

Read Next: Hello Bello Diapers Review: A-List Diapers For Your Little One

Read Next: A Review Of Abby And Finn Diapers, 2021: Budget-Friendly, But Is That Enough?

Where to buy All Good Diapers?

All Good diapers are exclusive to Walmart. You can find them both in-store and online!

Do All Good Diapers work? 

Reviews of All Good diapers are actually super positive. They score an average of 4.6 out of 5 in over 4100 reviews. Reviewers generally say they’re good at keeping leaks at bay and they’re not bulky, and parents like their simple designs. Some users have had issues with leaking though.

All Good Diapers FAQ

1. Are all good diapers organic?

There’s nothing to suggest that All Good diapers are organic. They’re made mainly with petroleum-based plastics, and they don’t offer information regarding any plant-based materials used, so I have to assume they don’t have any eco-credentials. That means they’re certainly not organic, unfortunately.

Related Post: What Are The Best Organic Diapers On The Market, And Why You Should Look For The Most Natural Ingredients

2. All Good Diapers vs Pampers: which ones are better?

It’s safe to say that Pampers is the biggest diaper brand in the world. But just because it’s the most widely available brand, doesn’t mean it’s the best. In fact, Pampers is one of the worst brands when it comes to using eco-friendly and skin-friendly ingredients. 

Pampers offers a long list of diaper varieties, from swim diapers to training pants. Pampers Pure Protection is the only variety that makes an effort to avoid some toxins and use some plant-based materials. The rest, I have to assume, contain nasty toxins like phthalates, fragrances, and lotions. 

Read Next: Pampers Pure Protection Review: Are They Really Pure?

All Good diapers are a little better, as they do make their ingredients clear and they avoid fragrances, lotions, and latex. But there’s no word on phthalates and they’re only elemental chlorine-free, not totally chlorine-free, like so many other brands (Eco Pea, Healthynest, Dyper, etc.). 

All Good diapers are certainly the better choice between the two, but biodegradable, non-toxic, and organic brands are far superior!

Read More: The Best Non-Toxic Diapers For Your Baby: Chemical-Free, Hypoallergenic, And Environmentally Friendly

Pampers vs All Good Diapers Comparison Table
Pampers Baby DryPampers Pure ProtectionAll Good
Free of phthalates?NoNoNo
Free of fragrances?NoYesYes
Use of plant-based materials?NoYes – someCore only
Price per diaper (size 3)$0.25*$0.37*$0.22*

*Prices were accurate at the time this article was published but may change over time.

3. All Good Diapers vs Huggies: what’s the Difference?

Just like Pampers, Huggies is one of the most popular brands worldwide. And just like Pampers, Huggies don’t appear to prioritize skin and planet-friendly ingredients.

Huggies Snug ‘n’ Dry steer clear of fragrances and latex, but they don’t use any plant-based materials and it looks like they contain phthalates. Huggies Special Delivery diapers are slightly better, with the use of some plant-based materials, but, again, it looks like phthalates are used. 

Read Next: Huggies Special Delivery Diapers Review: A Green Choice, Or Greenwashed?

Plus, their Special Delivery diapers are super expensive compared with similar brands – 37 cents per diaper for a pack of size 3 diapers from Walmart. 

While Huggies Special Delivery might be slightly better for the environment than All Good diapers, for that price, you could get biodegradable diapers like Dyper and Ecoriginals

Huggies vs All Good Diapers Comparison Table
Huggies Special DeliveryHuggies Snug ‘n’ DryAll Good
Free of phthalates?NoNoNo
Free of fragrances?YesYesYes
Use of plant-based materials?Yes – someNoCore only
Price per diaper (size 3)$0.40*$0.25*$0.22*

*Prices were accurate at the time this article was published but may change over time.

4. All Good Diapers vs Hello Bello: which diapers are better?

Hello Bello is the brainchild of Kristen Bell and her husband Dax Shepard. They set out to create healthy diapers that don’t break the bank, and that’s exactly what you get with their brand. 

Hello Bello diapers aren’t the best for the environment – they only use a small percentage of plant-based materials. But they do stay away from chlorine, phthalates, fragrances, and lotions, which is great news for our little ones’ sensitive skin. They’re a little more expensive than All Good diapers, but they’re more than worth it if your budget can stretch to it. 

Read Next: Hello Bello Diapers Review: A-List Diapers For Your Little One

Plus, just like All Good, Hello Bello has a charity partnership. In fact, they donated over a million diapers to those in need in 2019 alone. 

Hello Bello vs All Good Diapers Comparison Table
Hello BelloAll Good
Free of phthalates?YesNo
Free of fragrances?YesYes
Use of plant-based materials?Yes – someCore only
Price per diaper (size 3)$0.33*$0.22*

*Prices were accurate at the time this article was published but may change over time.

All Good Diapers Alternatives 

If you’re looking for diaper companies that do good and offer truly eco and skin-friendly diapers, there are plenty of brands doing things a little better than All Good diapers.

Brands realize that we want more, and many are delivering.

The best diapers you can buy on the market right now are those which use plant-based materials – even better if they’re biodegradable. The best diapers avoid toxins like phthalates, fragrances, and lotions, and the best of the best do something more to help protect our planet or each other. 

These are the best alternatives to All Good diapers!

DiaperAll GoodMillie MoonAbby & FinnHello BelloDyperEco Pea
Free of chlorine?NoYesYesYesYesYes
Free of phthalates?NoYesYesYesYesYes
Free of fragrances and lotions?YesYesYesYesYesYes
Made with plant-based materials?Core onlySomeCore onlyCore onlyYesYes
Biodegradable?NoNoNoNoYesYes
Approx price per diaper (size 3)*$0.22$0.28$0.28$0.35$0.41$0.62
Donate to charity?YesYesYesYesNo, but they
purchase
carbon offsets
Yes
Read MoreInfoInfoInfoInfoInfoInfo

*Prices were accurate at the time this article was published but may change over time.

It’s pretty clear that brands like Dyper and Eco Pea are the cream of the crop – offering biodegradable, plant-based diapers that are completely free of potentially harmful chemicals and toxins. They also do their bit for the world around us by purchasing carbon offsets or partnering with charities and good causes. 

Related Post: Dyper Diapers Review: Eco-Friendly, Skin-Friendly And Bank Account-Friendly

Related Post: Eco Pea Diapers Review: Super Soft, Sustainable And Saving The Planet

They’re a little higher on price, so if you’re looking for a more budget-friendly diaper, brands like Abby & Finn are the next best, for sure. They don’t use a high percentage of plant-based materials, unfortunately, but the price is great, they steer clear of toxins, and they donate a portion of their profits to charity.

The good, the bad, the bottom line: Is All Good a good diaper brand?

The Good

  • Elemental chlorine-free
  • Free of latex
  • Fragrance-free
  • Free of parabens
  • Money-back guarantee
  • Hypoallergenic
  • ‘Around the clock’ leak protection
  • The brand donates to Feeding America
  • Great reviews

The Bad

  • They’re not the cheapest
  • They might contain phthalates
  • They’re not totally free of chlorine
  • No eco-credentials

The bottom line: Are All Good diapers any good?

I can’t help but be very disappointed by All Good diapers. Their brand name is super misleading. A brand that calls their diapers ‘All Good’ should be offering completely non-toxic diapers at the very least. But it looks like these exclusive-to-Walmart diapers could contain phthalates, and they’re not completely chlorine-free either.

It’s fantastic that the brand partners with a great cause. But, if they truly want to appeal to millennials, they need to improve their ingredients. We want the best for our babies, and, despite the brand name, All Good just ain’t it.

Related Reading