Pampers Baby Dry vs. Swaddlers: Which Diaper Is Best For My Baby?

While it’s great that there’s so much choice when it comes to diapers, choosing a brand can be a minefield. And just when you’ve chosen a brand, you realize there are more varieties of a diaper in that brand than there are coffees on a Starbucks menu. We all know that Pampers is tried and tested, but that doesn’t mean that all of its diapers will suit you and your little one. So which one will?

It’s no surprise that Pampers is one of the most used brands not just in the US, but globally. Whether it’s large grocery store chains, small independent shops, or online, if a shop sells diapers, chances are, they offer Pampers. But with eight varieties of the brand and each designed for different ages or stages, choosing the right one for you and your family isn’t necessarily easy.

Pampers Swaddlers and Pampers Baby Dry are some of the most popular and widely available diapers offered by the Pampers brand, with Swaddlers offering a super soft diaper and Baby Dry, shockingly, a super absorbent one.

Let’s take a closer look at Swaddlers vs Baby Dry: who they’re for, what they’re made from, and everything in-between!

Pampers Swaddlers vs Baby-dry

Pampers Swaddlers Vs Baby-Dry Differences

SwaddlersBaby Dry
Softnesssofterless soft
Wetness indicatorYes – in all sizesOnly in sizes newborn-2
Price Range23-43 cents per diaper20-33 cents per diaper

Pampers Swaddlers Vs Baby-Dry Similarities

SwaddlersBaby Dry 
Sizes Availablenewborn-6newborn-6
Effectiveness Up to 12 hours of protectionUp to 12 hours of protection
Added fragranceyesyes

Note: Affiliate links may be used in this post. I may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you if you make a purchase through my affiliate link. Please read my disclosure for more info.

Pampers Swaddlers vs Baby-Dry: in-depth comparison

Pampers Swaddlers Review

Features

Pampers Swaddlers to the diaper market are what Beyonce is to music: pretty much always number 1. The first choice for hospitals, nurses, and parents in America, they have a lot to live up to. The softest offering from Pampers, not only are they great for newborns and their delicate skin, but they’ll keep your little one dry for up to 12 hours. And fewer diaper changes are never a bad thing…

Pampers Swaddlers aren’t just soft; they feature a wetness indicator, so you know exactly when to change. These are super handy for parents, and especially new parents. I remember laughing in disbelief when changing my little one’s 15th diaper of the day. ‘Not again’ was certainly my most used phrase in those first months! 

They feature what Pampers call  ‘heart quilts’, which, to be honest, sound a lot fancier than they are. They’re quite literally heart shapes on the diaper, which, of course, make no difference to its absorbency whatsoever. Sounds cute though, so I guess that’s all that matters! 

The smaller sizes also have an umbilical cord notch to protect your little one’s delicate and sensitive skin when they’re newborn, so it’s easy to see why they’re a popular choice in hospitals. 

Materials

It’s all well and good focusing on a diaper’s absorbency or softness, but what’s really important is the materials that provide these elements. You might not have thought about it before, but there are actually loads of nasty chemicals lurking in your baby’s diaper. And you’d be completely forgiven for not realizing – it’s not like diaper brands advertise it. I doubt ‘heart quilts with some petroleum-based plastics and a few likely-to-cause-a-rash lotions’ would sound appealing to parents and carers.

This is why I’m really reluctant to buy diapers unless they make their ingredients super clear. We’re lucky in that many brands do, especially the smaller, more eco-friendly companies. And in fact, Pampers does make their ingredients clear, which is a great first step. The problem lies with the list itself. It doesn’t exactly inspire confidence in Pampers’ ability to keep our babies’ skin healthy, and they’re not doing much for the planet, either.

So what about Pampers Swaddlers. What exactly are they made from, and are there any hidden toxins we should be wary of?

Do Pampers Swaddlers contain chlorine?

Think chlorine and you probably think swimming pools. Weirdly, the same chlorine that’s used to treat bacteria in pools can also be found in baby diapers. Who knew? Unlike its purpose in pools, which is pretty crucial, it’s actually used completely unnecessarily in diapers. So what’s it for? To make them more absorbent. Makes sense, until you know that there are much more eco-friendly ways of doing this, and yet some companies continue to use chlorine… because it’s cheaper. Yep. The same companies who make millions in profits choose chlorine to – well – to increase their profits even more. This is why eco-friendly brands like the Honest Company and Dyper make a big deal of leaving it out of their products and thank the diaper Lords that they do!

Pampers explain that it’s the absorbent core in Swaddlers which is made with ‘elemental chlorine-free’ fluff pulp. Elemental chlorine-free means the process is slightly better for the environment than regular chlorine bleaching, but, ideally, we’re looking for diapers to be ‘totally chlorine-free’. 

Do Pampers Swaddlers use added fragrances?

On the surface, the addition of fragrances in diapers seems like a pretty good idea. We all know how diaper smells love to linger, clinging on to every inch of the room you change your little one in, as well as your clothes somehow. Lovely. 

But added fragrances are anything but positive. The term is actually used to hide the presence of some nasty chemicals, and this term isn’t regulated by the FDA. Pampers doesn’t tell us what they really mean by ‘fragrances’ and, considering our babies wear these things 24/7 for a good 3 years, it’s kinda important. 

Do Pampers Swaddlers use SAP (super absorbent polymer)?

‘Super absorbent polymer’ doesn’t sound like the friendliest of additions to baby diapers, but it’s actually not thought to be harmful. This is the bit that works to wick away all the moisture and keep your little one dry, and you’ll find it in all diapers, from plastic-heavy, budget-friendly varieties to super eco-friendly and plant-based varieties. 

Do Pampers Swaddlers use petroleum-based plastics?

You might have noticed the influx of ‘plant-based’, ‘non-toxic’, ‘eco-friendly’ and ‘organic’ diapers to the market in recent years. This is great for our little ones and for the world around us; sustainable, plant-based materials like bamboo are naturally better for the environment than the use of plastics, and gentler on baby’s skin, too. Unfortunately, Pampers Swaddlers are made predominantly with (very unsustainable) petroleum-based plastics. While you’ll probably find some plastics in most diapers, eco-friendly or not, it’s a shame that Pampers don’t seem to be backing the environmentally-friendly thing, at least not with their Swaddlers variety. 

Do Pampers Swaddlers use inks and dyes?

Another diaper addition that appears pretty non-threatening is inks. There’s a reason why many diapers are plastered with cute prints; for parents, it’s a selling point! Babies don’t even get to see them though, so, really, it’s another pointless exercise. Some inks and dyes contain heavy metals, which can irritate your baby’s skin, so they’re best avoided if possible. Some brands use plant-based dyes, which appear to be fine in terms of skin health. 

Looking at Pampers Swaddlers, the brand states that their printed back sheet features dyes “commonly used in a wide range of products” like food packaging and colored contact lenses1. While this makes them sound pretty safe, just because it’s used in other household products, doesn’t mean it’s suitable for babies! Pampers are unclear when it comes to heavy metals in their dyes. Their site states that their inks are lead and mercury-free, but given that there are 8 heavy metals, who’s to say that they don’t contain others? It’s a shame that clever marketing often tries to trick consumers, although I doubt that they’d sell so many if they were clear!

Brands that stay away from heavy metal dyes, like Andy Pandy and Dewor, state very obviously that they’re not used, no guesswork involved.

Do Pampers Swaddlers use lotions?

Yet another addition to Swaddlers which seems like a positive is lotions. This one is made from petrolatum, aloe extract, and stearyl alcohol, and they state that this is designed to hydrate the skin. All good so far, right? Except that the use of alcohol can irritate your little one’s skin and eco, skin-friendly brands prefer to steer clear of it. We can keep the aloe though…

Do Pampers Swaddlers contain phthalates?

I must apologize. If you’ve read any of my other diaper reviews, you’re probably pretty tired of me rambling on about phthalates. Feel free to skip this section if you’re clued up! But chances are, you’ve not heard of the term before, and they’re additions that you should definitely take note of. Phthalates are chemicals found in all sorts of products like vinyl flooring and toys. Oh, and baby diapers. So what’s the issue?

The use of phthalates has been linked to an increased risk of asthma development in children1 and, even more shockingly, abnormal genital development in little boys. Suffice to say, avoid them if you can. 

The problem is that the use of phthalates isn’t regulated by the FDA, so brands are under no obligation to declare their use. Frustratingly, Pampers is one of these brands. And I always say it’s safer to assume that they are used, unless a brand shouts about the fact that they’re not. Considering how potentially harmful they are, why wouldn’t a brand highlight their avoidance of them? It leads me to believe that Pampers Swaddlers do contain these horrible phthalates. 

Pampers Swaddlers Size Chart

NewbornSize 1Size 2Size 3Size 4Size 5Size 6
WeightUp to 10 lbs8-14 lbs12-18 lbs16-28 lbs22-37 lbs27+ lbs35+ lbs

Reviews

Given that they’re the first choice for many hospitals and parents, I’m expecting the reviews to be good. Great, even. And they certainly are. In fact, they average 4.8 out of 5 in over 29,000 reviews on Amazon, which should tell us everything we need to know. Chemicals aside, it’s obvious that Swaddlers work in terms of keeping your baby dry and comfortable. It’s just a huge shame that they’re not as eco and skin-friendly as they should be. 

Reviewers seem to love how super soft they are and how they really do prevent leaks. It’s clear that Swaddlers have somewhat of a cult following, with some parents saying they’d never switch to anything else!

Price

Given that Swaddlers are so readily available, the price of them will probably vary quite a bit. As a general rule though, big grocery stores and online shops like Amazon will offer the best prices for big brands, especially if you buy in bulk. Personally, I like to buy my diapers online. Not only do you often get the best deals, but they’re delivered to your door. It’s one less thing to think about when you’re shopping!

Looking at the price of Swaddlers on Amazon, you can get a pack of size 6, the largest size available in Swaddlers, for about 43 cents per diaper. You’ll pay 36 cents per diaper for size 5s, 31 cents per diaper for size 4s, 28 cents per diaper for size 3s, 25 cents per diaper for size 2s and 28 cents per diaper for size 1s. You’ll pretty much always find that smaller sizes are cheapest and these prices seem to be about average for the market. 

Some diapers will set you back as little as 16 cents per diaper, like Amazon’s own brand, Mama Bear Gentle Touch, and anything up to 80 cents+ per diaper, like some premium, plant-based brands. That’s not to say that all eco-friendly diapers are expensive; check out my top budget and environmentally friendly picks here!

So the price of Swaddlers is about average, but you could save even more when shopping on Amazon by using their Family Program. Never heard of it? It’s absolutely free for Prime members and when you sign up, you’ll get parenting tips, deals, and anything up to 20% of the diaper and baby food subscriptions. All in all, you can save quite a chunk of cash if you buy your diapers this way. 

Frequently Asked Questions about Pampers Swaddlers: 

1. What is the difference between Pampers Swaddlers and Swaddlers Sensitive?

The difference between Swaddlers and Swaddlers Sensitive is… not very clear. Both varieties claim to be hypoallergenic, although I’m wary of this because the term isn’t regulated by the FDA. Both varieties have the same features and, after looking at both, the only difference I could find in the marketing is the use of ‘gentle’ to describe Swaddlers Sensitive. The ingredients lists for both Swaddlers and Swaddlers Sensitive appear to be pretty much exactly the same too. I expected to see the omission of fragrances, lotions, and dyes in the latter, considering these are potential irritants and they’re supposedly for sensitive skin.

Pampers says that their Swaddlers Sensitive diapers feature aloe extract to soothe the skin, which seems like a unique feature. But their regular Swaddlers variety includes ‘skin protecting’ lotion with aloe extract. Confused? I certainly am. So if Pampers could let us know what makes Swaddlers Sensitive suitable for little ones with sensitive skin and different from the original Swaddlers, that would be super helpful!

2. Are Pampers Swaddlers good?

In terms of their ability to wick away moisture and keep your baby comfortable and dry, the reviews tell us that they’re certainly effective. The softest offering from Pampers, parents, and carers really like Swaddlers for newborns and many wouldn’t buy anything else. It’s really just their inclusion of potential toxins and lack of eco-friendly credentials which lets them down!

3. What diapers are comparable to Pampers Swaddlers?

Looking at Pampers’ arch-rival, Huggies, their Little Snugglers are pretty comparable to Pampers Swaddlers. Like Swaddlers, Huggies Little Snugglers are made predominantly from plastic and contain added inks and dyes. Plus, yet again, there’s no mention of phthalates, so they’re probably used in Little Snugglers too. They might be super soft, but they’re certainly not toxin-free.

Huggies Special Delivery diapers are also pretty similar to Pampers Swaddlers. They’re described as ‘the softest plant-based diaper available’, although I’m not sure whether they’d be able to back up that claim with science. Anyway, it’s great that Huggies’ soft offering is plant-based (wood fluff pulp); Pampers Swaddlers are made mostly with a petroleum-based plastic, although Pampers do produce a plant-based diaper, Pure Protection

Huggies Special Delivery claim to be hypoallergenic and are free of elemental chlorine, parabens, and fragrances. It’s also a huge positive that these diapers are free of fragrances, considering the term can be used to hide chemicals in diapers. But they do use dyes and lotions and there’s no mention of phthalates, which leads me to believe that they’re used in this variety.

If you’re looking for a super soft alternative to Pampers Swaddlers which ticks the eco-friendly and skin-friendly boxes, diapers made from bamboo are great choices. Andy Pandy diapers are one of my favorites. Made from silky, soft, and sustainable bamboo, these diapers are over 80% biodegradable and completely free from phthalates, chlorine, fragrances, lotions, and dyes. They have great reviews and I love that they’re a family company clearly determined to change the diaper world for the better!

Check out my other biodegradable and non-toxic picks for more fab choices.

The GoodThe Bad
◆ Super soft
◆ Free of latex, parabens, and PVC
◆ They feature a wetness indicator
◆ The number 1 choice for hospitals and parents
◆ They keep the baby dry for up to 12 hours
◆ Smaller sizes feature an umbilical cord notch
◆ Average price
◆ Available in all grocery stores and online
◆ Sizes newborn through 6
◆ They have great reviews
◆ They use chlorine bleaching
◆ They contain fragrances, but don’t specify what these are
◆ They have lotions
◆ Not free from phthalates
◆ They contain alcohol
◆ They’re made predominantly from plastic
◆ They contain inks and dyes with heavy metals
◆ They’re not eco-friendly
◆ They don’t use any plant-based or organic ingredients

The bottom line

So it’s clear that, when it comes to keeping your baby comfortable and dry, you can count on Pampers Swaddlers. Their softness and absorbency are preferred by many parents, carers, and hospitals, with the umbilical cord cutouts and wetness indicators as added bonuses. 

The problem is, there are lots of effective diapers out there and the market is moving on. It’s not enough to just ‘do the job’ anymore. We want – or, more accurately, need – a diaper that can keep our little ones dry while keeping their skin safe and doing as much as it can to save the world around us. The lack of any kind of eco-credentials and the use of potentially harmful toxins like phthalates, fragrances, and dyes really let Swaddlers down. It’s hoped that, with all the money and resources at Pampers’ disposal, they’re working towards a better diaper. 

Pampers Baby Dry Review

Pampers Baby Dry Features

With a name like ‘Baby Dry’, I’m expecting to see some fancy-pants absorbency claims from Pampers, and the ability to keep our babies dry for a good 12 hours. And, of course, this is what Baby Dry offers: great for overnights with up to 12 hours of protection, 3 ‘extra absorb’ channels, whatever that means, and all-around stretchy sides to fit your baby comfortably. They claim to be 3 times drier than the leading value brand, so, really, they should do the trick. 

The smaller sizes (newborn, 1, and 2) also feature a wetness indicator, to let you know when they need a change, and Pampers state that they’re ‘soft like cotton’ to keep your little one comfortable overnight. Presumably, they’re not quite as soft as their ‘softest’ variety, Swaddlers. They certainly like a soft diaper…

Materials

So where does Baby-Dry stand in the toxic materials stakes? Like Pampers Swaddlers, Pampers Baby-Dry diapers feature some hidden nasties and don’t make any real attempt to look after your baby’s skin or the environment. While both Swaddlers and Baby Dry claim to be hypoallergenic, so good for little ones with sensitive skin, it’s sensible to be wary of this claim, given that it’s not regulated by the FDA. Let’s take a closer look at what’s really inside Baby Dry diapers…

Do Pampers Baby Dry contain chlorine?

Yep, they certainly do. While elemental chlorine-free is an improvement, we’re really looking for diapers to be totally chlorine-free.

There are loads of brands out there who shout loudly and proudly about being completely chlorine-free, like Dewor, Hello Bello, and Dyper. Read everything you need to know about non-toxic diapers here!

Do Pampers Baby-Dry use added fragrances?

Pampers Baby-Dry diapers also contain added – and completely unnecessary – fragrances. You can see where this is going. They don’t explain what they actually mean by this, and it’s certainly best to steer clear of added fragrances if you can; they have the potential to irritate your little one’s skin. 

Do Pampers Baby Dry use SAP?

Super absorbent polymer is plastic-based, but not thought to be harmful to our little ones. It’s the bit that absorbs all the moisture (hence the name!) and you’ll find it in all disposable diapers, even plant-based, organic ones.‘

Do Pampers Baby Dry use petroleum-based plastics?

Like Swaddlers, Pampers Baby Baby Dry diapers are made predominantly with petroleum-based plastics. Pretty much all diapers made by larger brands like Pampers and Huggies use plastic as their main material, which obviously isn’t the best for the environment. In fact, it’ll take a few hundred years for diapers to decompose in a landfill, so your baby’s diapers will still be sat in a heap somewhere when your great-great-great-great-grandchildren are here! Or something like that… it’s a long time, anyway. 

There is a whole world of diapers out there, aside from the large brands, which are tackling this issue head-on and producing some seriously awesome eco-friendly alternatives. Bamboo, wood, and cane are super sustainable and much easier to decompose. They’re still not perfect, as they’re not all completely biodegradable, but it’s certainly an improvement on plastic. 

Related Post: Top Picks for the Best Biodegradable Diapers on the Market

Do Pampers Baby-Dry use inks and dyes?

Pampers Baby-Dry diapers feature ‘fun, colorful Sesame Street characters and designs’. While these are undeniably cute, who are they really for? When your little ones are wearing the diapers, they won’t even be able to see the patterns! 

The problem is, inks and dyes can contain heavy metals, which have the potential to irritate your baby’s skin. Some brands use plant-based inks and dyes, but it doesn’t look like Pampers have made that change just yet. I don’t know about you, but as long as the diaper can hold in what it’s supposed to (minus some inevitable poop explosions), I’m not too worried about what it looks like.

They state that their inks are made ‘without disperse dyes’, but, despite my best efforts, I cannot work out what this means. Is it a good thing? Google throws up some seriously scientific facts about disperse dyes that my right-brained, creative mind isn’t a fan of. Could Pampers explain what this means for the average non-science-degree-holding parent, please?

Do Pampers Baby-Dry use lotions?

I sound like a broken record, but again, like Swaddlers, Pampers Baby-Dry diapers contain their ‘skin protecting lotion’. They claim that this hydrates the skin, but the addition of alcohol seems unnecessary, and a little worrying. The purest diapers are those which stay away from anything unnecessary like added fragrances, dyes, and lotions, and there’s plenty of choices…  

Related Post: What Are The Best Organic Diapers On The Market, And Why You Should Look For The Most Natural Ingredients

Do Pampers Baby-Dry contain phthalates?

Here we go again – yes. I mean, they don’t state this anywhere, but they also don’t tell us they’re phthalate-free either. It’s always safer to assume that phthalates are present unless the brand makes it crystal clear on their packaging or website that they’re avoided. Considering that these hormone disruptors can be pretty easily absorbed by the skin, it’s a shame that Pampers don’t take steps to eliminate them in their products. 

Pampers Baby Dry Size Chart

NewbornSize 1Size 2Size 3Size 4Size 5Size 6
WeightUp to 10 lbs8-14 lbs12-18 lbs16-28 lbs22-37 lbs27+ lbs35+ lbs

Reviews

So Pampers Baby-Dry diapers don’t fare so well on the non-toxic side of things, but are they at least effective? Their focus is clearly on overnights and keeping your baby comfortable, but do parents and carers agree?

Heading over to Amazon, they average a very decent 4.7 out of 5 in over 8,700 reviews. That’s a lot of time spent writing about diapers. But who am I to talk?

Lots of reviewers say they’ve never had to worry about leaks, even overnight, and they’ve helped their baby to sleep better. Having said that, there are some reviewers who aren’t happy with the latest diapers, saying that they seem to be thinner than they were previously, and are not quite as effective. 

Price

The price of Pampers Baby-Dry diapers is comparable to the price of Swaddlers, although a little cheaper on average. Size 1 diapers on Amazon are pretty cheap, only setting you back 20 cents per diaper, while size 2s will cost you 21 cents per diaper. Size 3s work out slightly more – 23 cents per diaper – with size 4s and 5s costing 25 cents and 30 cents per diaper respectively. Finally, size 6s are the most expensive, unsurprisingly, at 33 cents per diaper. 

Overall, it’s fair to say that Pampers Baby Dry are a pretty budget-friendly variety!

Frequently Asked Questions about Pampers Baby-Dry: 

1. Are Pampers Baby-Dry overnight diapers?

Baby-Dry aren’t just for overnights, but given their super absorbency, they’re certainly appropriate for them. If there’s one thing that’s gonna wake your little one – aside from milk cravings – it’s a leaky diaper. Wearing a super-absorbent diaper overnight should keep them comfortable and dry, and help them to get a good night’s rest. In theory.

2. Do Pampers Baby-Dry have a fragrance?

Pampers Baby-Dry diapers do feature added fragrances. This might sound like a positive thing, but actually, fragrances are both unnecessary and potentially harmful to the skin. The term isn’t regulated by the FDA and it could be used to sneak in harsh chemicals that aren’t the friendliest to your little one. Ultimately, they’re not gonna stay smelling ‘nice’ for long, so I do not understand why they’re used!

3. What diapers are comparable to Pampers Baby-Dry?

The obvious alternative to Pampers Baby-Dry would be to head over to Huggies and their overnight diapers, aptly named ‘OverNites’. Like Baby Dry and Swaddlers, OverNites offer up to 12 hours of protection to help your baby sleep comfortably. Available in sizes 3 through 6, they contain added dyes but seem to steer clear of fragrances and lotions. There’s no mention of phthalates though, so I’m assuming they’re used. 

Like Swaddlers, they’re super soft – actually, ‘pajama-like’ soft – but while they’re effective, they don’t carry any eco-credentials and feature added inks, which might contain heavy metals.

Looking for an alternative to Baby Dry that’s gentle on the skin, and on the environment? Honest diapers produce a specific overnight diaper, which also offers up to 12 hours of protection for your little one. The difference is, Honest overnight diapers are totally free from chlorine, hypoallergenic, made from sustainably managed wood pulp, and steer clear of phthalates. I’m a fan. 

If you’re looking to go full saving-the-planet when it comes to your diapers, try a biodegradable pick. Bamboo is a popular material for eco-friendly diapers, given its sustainability, softness, and absorbency. Companies like Dyper and Andy Pandy produce bamboo diapers that are super absorbent and, just because they don’t produce a specific ‘overnight’ diaper doesn’t mean they won’t work for nights! 

Both have great reviews and you could always try booster pads like those from Sposie to pop inside your eco-friendly diapers for nighttime. While Sposie pads are made from plastic, they’re hypoallergenic, cruelty-free, and free from phthalates, chlorine, fragrances, and latex. They’re sure to keep your little one dry and they’re gentle on the skin.

Next to read: Best Overnight Diapers For Your Baby: 8 Top Picks

The GoodThe Bad
◆ The smaller sizes feature a wetness indicator
◆ They keep the baby dry for up to 12 hours
◆ Great for overnight
◆ Budget-friendly price
◆ Available in all grocery stores and online
◆ Available in sizes newborn through 6
◆ They have pretty good reviews
◆ They use chlorine bleaching
◆ They contain fragrances, but don’t specify what these are
◆ They have lotions
◆ Not free from phthalates
◆ They contain alcohol
◆ They’re made predominantly from plastic
◆ They contain inks and dyes with heavy metals
◆ They’re not eco-friendly
◆ They don’t use any plant-based or organic ingredients

The bottom line

If absorbency is your priority over softness, Pampers Baby-Dry appears to be the better choice. Both Swaddlers and Baby-Dry are absorbent and do the job, but Pampers are clearly marketing Baby Dry as the diaper of choice for heavy wetters and for overnights. Like with Swaddlers though, while they’re effective, they’ve got a long way to go when it comes to protecting the environment and our little ones’ skin. 

Frequently Asked Questions about Pampers Swaddlers vs Baby Dry: 

1. What is the difference between Pampers Baby-Dry and Pampers Swaddlers overnight?

So Pampers describe their BabyDry variety as ‘all night protection’, and Swaddlers Overnights as ‘nighttime protection’. The same thing, then. Both of course claim to be super absorbent, and I guess the only real difference between the varieties is that Swaddlers Overnights can still boast the whole ‘heart quilts liner’ and ‘blankie softness’ thing. Both have a wetness indicator and both state that they’ll keep your little one dry and protected for up to 12 hours.

Swaddlers Overnights and Baby Dry both have good reviews, although Swaddlers Overnights are only available in sizes 3 through 6, whereas Baby Dry offers a wider size range – newborn to 6. The other difference between them is that Swaddlers Overnights seem to be a little more expensive, which isn’t surprising given that they’re just as effective as Baby Dry but softer. It’ll set you back 37 cents per diaper on Amazon for a pack of size 3 Swaddlers Overnights, compared to 23 cents per diaper for size 3 BabyDry

2. Are Huggies or Pampers better?

It’s the age-old diaper rivalry: Huggies or Pampers? Both brands have fans who are fiercely loyal and often won’t use anything else on their little ones. Huggies and Pampers both offer a wide range of different diapers for the various stages of diaper-wearing and, to be honest, their offerings are pretty similar. 

Here’s a breakdown of their diapers:

Age, Stages, and PurposesPampersHuggies
NewbornsSwaddlersLittle Snugglers
Active infants and toddlersCruisersLittle Movers
Older infantsBaby-DrySnug & Dry
Potty training Easy UpsPull Ups
SwimmingSplashersLittle Swimmers
OvernightsSwaddlers OvernightsOverNites
Eco-friendly (sort of)Pure ProtectionSpecial Delivery
Sensitive SkinSwaddlers SensitiveLittle Snugglers

They’re super popular brands for good reason. They’re experts in keeping your little one dry and comfortable, and most reviews are pretty positive. 

The problem is, both brands use a smorgasbord of toxins in their diapers, which are actually completely unnecessary. Both use chlorine bleaching and some of their varieties feature fragrances, lotions, and dyes, which have the potential to irritate your little one’s skin. Most importantly, neither Huggies nor Pampers are transparent about their use of phthalates. Silence on the issue speaks volumes, it’s safer to assume unless it’s stated otherwise, that they are used. 

And when it comes to looking after the planet, neither brand makes much of an effort to effect real change. Pampers produce ‘Pure Protection’, a plant-based diaper that isn’t phthalate-free or biodegradable. Huggies Special Delivery diapers are also plant-based and are fragrance-free, but they still contain chlorine and aren’t able to be composted. 

Ultimately, while all Pampers and Huggies varieties are likely to ‘do the job’, they’re really lagging behind; there are so many diaper brands out there that not only ‘do the job’, but go the extra mile for your little one’s health and for the health of the planet. Click on the links for more information on eco-friendly, hypoallergenic and non-toxic diaper picks.

Related Post: Huggies Vs. Pampers 2020: Which Is The Best Diaper Brand For Your Baby?

Final thoughts: Pampers Swaddlers vs Baby-Dry

Both Pampers Swaddlers and Pampers Baby-Dry will certainly – well – keep your baby dry. Swaddlers appear to be a softer version of Baby Dry, so I’d say they’re probably better for newborns. They’re a little more expensive, but I’m sure that babies who’ve just been thrust from a comfy cozy womb into the big wide world will appreciate that extra softness! 

Baby Dry aren’t just for overnight, but they’re certainly good for them, although both Swaddlers and Baby Dry claim to keep your little one dry and comfortable for up to 12 hours. So the addition of Pampers Swaddlers Overnights seems kinda unnecessary, although I guess there’s the extra softness. 

Both Pampers Swaddlers and Pampers Baby Dry are hugely popular choices and, according to the great reviews, for a reason: they work! But look deeper into the brand, its materials, and its impact on the environment, they’re hardly winning a gold medal in the race for skin and world-friendly diaper production. Pampers, like Huggies, use unnecessary added toxins in their diapers, like phthalates and dyes and they don’t make a particular effort to choose eco-friendly, plant-based materials either. 

I really hope that big brands like Pampers look at the demand for diapers like Honest and Dyper, who strive to make the healthiest products for our little ones and for the planet, whilst also delivering diapers that work! With all of Pampers’ money and resources, it’s safe to say they have the means. We’re waiting (not so patiently), Pampers!

References:

  1. Jaakkola, J. J., & Khinght, T. L. (2008). The role of exposure to phthlates from polyvinyl chloride products in the development of asthma and allergies: a systematic review and metaanalysis. Environ Health Perspect, 116(7), 845-53.

Related Reading