GoodNites vs Ninjamas: Which is best?

When it comes to the world of bedwetting underwear, there are two brands that dominate. Goodnites and Ninjamas are undoubtedly the most popular bedwetting brands on the market right now, and when you look at the glowing reviews, it’s easy to see why.

Offering great protection for little ones through to older children (and even teens and adults in the case of Goodnites), both products promise to keep wearers comfortable and dry. 

But which is the best?

Note: Affiliate links may be used in this post. I may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you if you make a purchase through my affiliate link. Please read my disclosure for more info. All prices and availability are accurate at the time of publishing.

 a box of Ninjamas and a box of Goodnites pants

Goodnites vs Ninjamas Comparison Table

Let’s compare the top bedweting underwear brands like-for-like. Which comes out on top?

AbsorbencyMore absorbentLess absorbent
Sizing XS – XL (28-140lbs+)S/M – L/XL (38-95lbs+)
Any plant-based materials?NoNo
Price per diaper (Girls S/M)$0.66$0.64
Reviews on Amazon4.8 out of 54.6 out of 5

Ninjamas and Goodnites are clearly very similar in terms of what they offer. Both have very positive reviews, are a similar price and, unfortunately, don’t boast any eco credentials

It’s great that Goodnites offers such a wide variety of sizes, and it’s even better that they avoid fragrances.

What company makes Ninjamas and Goodnites?

Ninjamas are made by Procter & Gamble. P&G also make Pampers, that little old diaper brand that’s been doing quite well for some years now. 

Goodnites are manufactured by Kimberly-Clark, the same global company that makes Huggies. They also make Andrex, Cottonelle and Kleenex.

In-depth side by side comparison: Do Ninjamas or Goodnites Hold More?

Goodnites bedwetting underwear promises to hold up to the equivalent of 2 bottles of water, which is pretty impressive. Ninjamas simply say that they’re absorbent. Looking at reviews, it looks like Ninjamas are, as a rule, slightly less absorbent than Goodnites. Some say that they’re prone to leaks if the child wearing them is a heavy wetter. 

Ninjamas vs Goodnites: Features Comparison

Goodnites bedwetting underwear features double leg barriers, which prevent leaks. They also feature ‘odor absorption technology’, whatever that is, and unique absorption zones in the pants for boys and the pants for girls. 

It’s pretty amazing that these pull-ups can hold the equivalent of 2 bottles of water!

Goodnites tells us that their pull-ups are super stretchy and the smaller sizes even feature exclusive Disney designs.

Looking at Ninjamas, this bedwetting underwear features ‘LockAway Channels’ – in other words, super absorbent bits which deal with wetness and keep your child dry.

Ninjamas also feature OdorMask Technology, but, like Goodnites’ odor control technology, there’s no explanation from Ninjamas as to what this actually is.

Ninjamas vs Goodnites: Velcro or Easy-tear Sides?

Both Ninjamas and Goodnites feature easy tear sides rather than velcro sides. 

Velcro sides feature on Huggies Pull-Ups, and let you check and change pull-ups without having to remove pants. But some parents and carers say that velcro sides can irritate the skin. Easy tear sides can’t be refastened like velcro sides can.

Read Next: Which Pull-Ups Have Refastenable Sides? The Best Pull-Ups With Velcro Sides

Ninjamas vs Goodnites: What age are Ninjamas for? What age are Goodnites for?

Ninjamas bedtime underwear is suitable for children who weigh 38-95lbs+. So they’re good for little ones when they’re 3-4, right through to older children. They’ll fit some young adults too. 

When it comes to Goodnites, their smallest size – XS – is suitable for toddlers who weigh 28-43lbs. They’re available through to size XL. This size is suitable for those who weigh 95-140lbs+ – older children, teenagers, and even young adults.

Ninjamas vs Goodnites: Ingredients

Not all diaper, pull-up and bedwetting underwear brands make their ingredients clear. And they should. 

We need to know what’s in the products that sit next to the skin for hours every day. 

And given that billions of diapers head to landfill every year in the US alone, we need to choose products that make an effort to use less plastic wherever we can. 

Luckily, Ninjamas provides a full list of materials used to make them:

Topsheet – Polypropylene
Backsheet – Polypropylene & polyethylene
The absorbent core – Fluff pulp and SAP (Super Absorbent Polymer)

It looks like the majority of a Ninjama pant is made with some form of petroleum-based plastic.

And what about Goodnites? The brand offers a full list of ingredients used in its products:

Topsheet and Backsheet – Polypropylene, Polyethylene, Polyurethane
The absorbent core – Wood pulp and SAP

Like Ninjamas, most Goodnites components are made with petroleum-based plastics. 

Ninjamas vs Goodnites: Safe or Toxic?

Diapers, pull-ups and bedwetting underwear would be the last products you’d expect to contain toxins. But these products commonly contain chemicals that can irritate the skin, and worse. 

Added scents and fragrances are often used in pull-ups and bedwetting underwear. It might seem like a good idea, but it’s anything but. The terms aren’t regulated by the FDA, which means diaper companies can use them to ‘cover’ a smorgasbord of chemicals and toxins. 

More on this topic: Disposable Diapers: What Are They Made From, And Are They Safe?

Ninjamas use added fragrances in their products, which is bad news for skin, especially for those with sensitive skin. Goodnites, on the other hand, are free of fragrances.

The other important chemical to avoid is phthalates, which can be found in all sorts of everyday products, from baby toys to flooring. A 2014 study found that phthalate exposure could ‘perturb normal development’ as the chemicals can interfere with hormones

If a bedwetting pant brand isn’t clear about the use of phthalates, it’s much safer to assume that they’re used. There’s nothing to suggest that Ninjamas and Goodnites are free of phthalates, so I assume they’re used.

Ninjamas vs Goodnites: Pricing

How much are Goodnites pull-ups vs Ninjamas? 

Let’s look at the price of Ninjamas over on Amazon.

Ninjamas prices on Amazon

Boys’ SizePrice per pantGirls’ SizePrice per pant
S/M (44 count)$0.64S/M (44 count)$0.64
L/XL (68 count)$0.82L/XL (68 count)$0.82

*Prices were accurate at the time this article was published but may change over time.

And how does that compare with Goodnites?

Goodnites prices on Amazon

Boys’ SizePrice per pantGirls’ SizePrice per pant
XS (44 count)$0.68XS (44 count)$0.68
S/M (44 count)$0.66S/M (99 count)$0.66
L (75 count)$0.87L (75 count)$0.87
XL (63 count)$1.03XL (63 count)$1.03

*Prices were accurate at the time this article was published but may change over time.

Let’s compare these prices to similar brands: Pampers Ninjamas and Bambo Nature Pants.

It’s clear that both Goodnites and Ninjamas are super similar when it comes to price. You might find them cheaper if you shop around, as both brands are available in large grocery stores.

Ninjamas vs Goodnites: discreetness

Many Goodnites reviews talk about how discreet they are. Even adults who wear them say they’re super slim fitting, and you can’t tell that you’re wearing them under clothes, even tight fitting ones. 

Ninjamas also claim to be discreet. Like Goodnites, they have a slim silhouette, so there’s no need for kids to worry about using them away from home.

Alternatives to Ninjamas and Goodnites

Bambo Nature’s Night Pants are a brilliant alternative to both Ninjamas and Goodnites. This eco-friendlier brand makes bedwetting underwear in two sizes: age 4-7 (33-77lbs) and age 8-15 (77-110lbs). 

The brand also produces specifically-designed pants for girls and for boys.

They’re discreet and comfortable, and what’s even better is the company’s eco-credentials. They tell us that 85.4% of the waste from their production facility in Denmark was recycled in 2019. That’s not bad going!

Another brand to consider is Sposie. Sposie’s booster pads aren’t exactly an alternative to bedwetting underwear, but they’re great if you’re looking for added protection. These booster pads are made to fit into diapers, bedwetting underwear or regular cotton underwear, providing extra absorbency and extra protection. In fact, the brand claims that its pads can double the absorbency of kids’ or adult diapers. 

Simply pop one inside your chosen bedwetting underwear, and away you go.

And the best thing about them is they’re free of nasty chemicals like phthalates, chlorine and fragrances.

Conclusion: Which is Better – Ninjamas or Goodnites?

It’s clear that Goodnites and Ninjamas are pretty similar. Both offer softness, super absorbency and comfort.

Goodnites can boast holding the equivalent of up to 2 bottles of water. And they’re also super discreet, even for adults under regular clothing. 

It’s also great that Goodnites offer such a wide range of sizes. They’re suitable for toddlers through to children and older children, and even some teens, young adults and adults. 

It’s a shame that they don’t boast any real eco credentials, but the fact that they’re fragrance-free is a positive.

The same can’t be said for Ninjamas, which do contain fragrances, and, most likely, a host of other chemicals. Like Goodnites, Ninjamas clearly work. Some parents and carers have experienced issues with leaks, though.

They offer a smaller range of sizes than Goodnites, with sizes suitable for children from 38-96lbs, they’ll fit older toddlers through to older children. 

When it comes to price and availability, there’s not much between Ninjamas and Goodnites. 

But, ultimately, it comes down to skin health. The fact that Goodnites are fragrance-free puts them ahead of Ninjamas. And if you want to go a step further when it comes to skin health and eco credentials, it’s worth looking outside of the big brands.

Bambo Nature offers bedwetting underwear for children through to teens. The brand  is undoubtedly leading the way, with its FSC-certified products that are free of fragrances, and free of phthalates.

There’s a very clear gap in the market for chemical-free, plant-based bedwetting pants. And let’s hope a brand fills it soon…

Related Reading